Hibbeler — Statics and Mechanics of Materials
Combined loadings — when a post carries weight and wind at the same time
Chapters 2 and 3 checked the foundry roof post against compression and wind uplift separately — this checks them together, since a post can pass both alone and still fail combined.
Concepts pulled in
- Combined stress (σ_total = P/A + Mc/I)
Chapters 2 and 3 checked the foundry roof post two different ways: compression/buckling under the roof's dead weight, and the connections under wind uplift pulling the roof up. What neither chapter checked is wind pushing sideways on the post while it's still carrying the roof's weight straight down — both loads happen at once, not one after the other.
Why this matters: a post that passes a pure-compression check and would separately pass a pure-bending check can still fail when both act together, because the combined stress isn't just the bigger of the two — it's closer to the sum. The combined-stress check is: σ_total = P/A + Mc/I, where P/A is the axial (compression) stress from Chapter 2, and Mc/I is the bending stress from the lateral wind force pushing on the post's exposed face.
Worked case
Same 4×4 treated post from Chapter 2, carrying the 675 lb roof load in compression. Wind pushing on the post's own face (not the roof — just the post itself, since the roof uplift case was already covered separately) adds a bending moment at the base. Even with a generous wind estimate, the bending stress this adds is small next to the post's bending capacity, and the combined total stays well under the allowable — this post was never close to its limit in either direction alone, so combining them doesn't change the verdict.
Answer
The teaching point is the method, not a surprise failure: check both loads together, don't assume passing each one separately is enough, especially as a build gets taller or the post gets slenderer.
Modern Monticello · Technical Library · Worked calculation
Combined loadings — when a post carries weight and wind at the same time
Hibbeler — Statics and Mechanics of Materials · Chapter 13
Project or part: (not named)
Try your own numbers
Starts on the Chapter 2 foundry roof post, with wind pushing on the post's own face while it carries the roof's weight. Make the post taller or slimmer, or turn the wind up, to see the two stresses add. Directionality (0.85) and gust (0.85) are the Chapter 3 values. Roof uplift is a separate check. The NDS caps a column's slenderness at 50, and an 8 ft 4×4 held only at its base (the first support option) is over that cap, so it is not an allowed column: Breyer Chapter 4 works this post under the NDS rules.
- Velocity pressure: qz = 0.00256 × 0.57 × 1 × 0.85 × 82.9² = 8.5 psf
- Pressure on the post face: p = qz × G × Cf = 8.5 × 0.85 × 2 = 14.5 psf, on the wide face (3.5 in) for the worst bending
- Line load on the post: 14.5 × 3.5 ÷ 12 = 4.23 lb/ft
- Bending moment: M = wL²/2 = 1,623 lb-in
- Axial stress: σ = P/A = 675 ÷ 12.25 = 55.1 psi
- Bending stress: Mc/I = M ÷ S = 1,623 ÷ 7.15 = 227.1 psi
- Combined: σ_total = P/A + Mc/I = 55.1 + 227.1 = 282.2 psi, which is 28% of the 1,000 psi allowable (weight alone is 5.5%)
Compared against the compression allowable, as the chapter does. The NDS also allows a higher stress for short wind gusts and checks bending against its own bending value, and neither is included here. This is a slender post: the lean under load adds some extra bending this does not count, so read it alongside Chapter 2's buckling margin. Worked example, not a stamped design.
Worked example from the Modern Monticello Technical Library, using published design values and simplified checks. Not a stamped engineering design: your site, materials and loads will differ, and anything that could hurt someone if it fails deserves a licensed engineer's review. Provisional or example values are placeholders, not measurements of your material. Sources for every number: modernmonticellobuild.com/technical-library/foundry-roof-post-combined-loading
Print this calculation
Prints just the calculator above, with your numbers and the working, on a clean white page headed with this chapter and today's date. Add a name if you want it on the sheet, for a build file or a plan set.